Law Times

Law TiMes • May 30, 2011 NEWS PAGE 3 Former escort turns life around to become lawyer Woman commits 'to conduct herself with honesty and integrity,' LSUC panel rules BY MICHAEL McKIERNAN Law Times O ne day in January 2004, Kathryn Smith- en made the decision to change her life. After 25 years of trouble with the law, including a string of fraud-related convictions and a spell in prison, her daughter had become aware that she was sur- viving economically as an escort. "Never again," Smithen promised her daughter that day before she set off on the path to a legal career. Th at summer, she applied to Osgoode Hall Law School. Seven years later, on May 11, she completed the turnaround when a Law Society of Upper Canada panel decided she possessed the good character necessary to prac- tise law in Ontario. "It's been a long journey, but I'm at a stage now where I'm very happy with what's happened and where I am and I'm trying to move forward in a positive way," Smithen tells Law Times in an interview. She's now looking forward to her call to the bar ceremony scheduled for the morning of June 17. "Despite her horrendous be- haviour in the past, she has come to grips with all of the reasons that propelled her to act so badly and has made a commitment to herself and others to conduct herself with honesty and integri- ty," wrote Bencher James Caskey on behalf of the three-member law society panel. Smithen's lawyer, Bill Trudell, had told the panel it would be easy for them to say no to her on the basis of her past. "But that's why law is such a great profession," Trudell said. "We look at the totality of the individual and not just certain aspects of their lives." For her part, Smithen isn't hiding her past. "I've certainly got some aspects of my life that are not admirable and had a lot to answer for but I'm really very privileged and honoured that the panel decided to agree with Mr. Trudell and decided that the sum total of my life experience sur- passed my less than admirable moments," she says. According to Smithen, the roots of her legal career lie in her childhood. "I've always been in- terested in social justice issues as a young girl. I did a lot of reading on them as a teenager. Unfortu- nately, along the way, I started having some problems in my late teens and pretty much ruled this out ever as a career," she notes. Smithen was born in 1962 in Winnipeg. A doctor who prac- tised in northern Manitoba ad- opted her 13 days later. She later moved with the family to On- tario, where her problems began. Between 1979 and 1993, she was convicted almost 40 times of off ences including fraud, theft of money and credit cards, and forging documents. Th e convic- tions culminated in an 18-month incarceration after the court ran out of patience with her spurned chances at rehabilitation. According to an agreed state- ment of facts fi led with the hear- ing, Smithen would pay the fi rst and last months' rent to landlords and then stay until the eviction process was complete. She also admitted she had stolen from em- ployers and had been dismissed for cause at least fi ve times. She married in 1987 but di- vorced her abusive husband in 1991. A Crown attorney who prosecuted Smithen's husband for assaults on her was one of several people who provided letters of support for her application. Between 1992 and 1999, and again from 2002 to 2004, Smithen was intermittently in- volved in the sex trade as an es- cort, according to the decision. She also collected social assis- tance for some of that time. A law society investigation also turned up evidence that she had posed as a landlord in 2004 in or- der to get credit bureau informa- tion about her former husband and his new spouse. She then used the information in family law proceedings against him. A Superior Court judge who ruled in the case turned over her 2006 judgment that was critical of some of Smithen's evidence to the law society after encountering her in chambers during her articles. Smithen has also declared bankruptcy twice. Th e last time was in 1995, when her liabilities totalled $470,000. She has been able to fund her studies with the help of a close friend who loaned her more than $300,000. Janice Duggan, counsel for the law society, argued that the large debt she still owed sug- gested Smithen was still spend- ing excessively and living be- yond her means. Duggan cast doubt on Smithen's remorse by highlight- ing her attempts to appeal her jail sentence and compensation orders against her. She has also applied twice for a pardon, ac- cording to the decision. But the panel was convinced of her remorse. It noted her fi rm position on cases where she felt she had been treated too harshly indicated "that she was not just saying what she thought the pan- el would want to hear." Panel members were also im- pressed with the commitment Smithen has shown since her graduation from Osgoode in June 2008. Since then, she has taken 27 continuing legal educa- tion programs and continued ses- sions with a psychotherapist. Th e panel granted her a li- cence to practise on the condi- tion that she continue to take therapy as needed; that she not operate a trust account as the sole lawyer signatory for the fi rst two years; and that she enter a two- year mentoring agreement with another lawyer in good standing with the law society. Smithen is now planning to start a family law practice as a Untitled-1 1www.lawtimesnews.com Barry S. Arbus, Q.C. specializes in business and corporate matters including acquisitions and mergers with an emphasis on international transactions. He is is the recipient of the Queen Elizabeth Medal in Recognition for Community Service. Barry's commitment to timely and cost effective service makes him the practical choice. Louie Reznick, LL.B. has mediated hundreds of cases over the years. Before transitioning to mediator Louie practised law for over 25 years, being certified by the Law Society as a Specialist in Civil Litigation. He has extensive experience in personal injury law, insurance law and contractual disputes. He has handled many difficult cases and dealt with demanding clients. He has experience and knows how to bring matters to successful resolution. adrchambers.com 416.362.8555 5/20/11 1:03:39 PM sole practitioner. "In trying to get licensed, I've met some really great people along the way and I've benefi ted from the enormous support of those people, includ- ing my daughter, my counsel, my extended family, and many members of the bar," she says. "I've also been treated exceed- ingly well by people at the law society and if I'm able to emulate that professionalism in my own law practice when I'm called to the bar, I think my clients are going to be in really great stead." Another lawyer applicant seeking redemption wasn't so successful at the law society ear- lier this month. Joram Gold, a former lawyer who was disbarred after serving a jail sentence for selling drugs out of his law offi ce, was denied a paralegal licence in a decision released on May 18. He had also applied for re-entry as a lawyer but abandoned that route in order to concentrate on the paralegal licence. A hearing panel found he hadn't met the burden of proof required to show that he was of good character. Bencher Linda Rothstein, writing for Kathryn Smithen is looking for- ward to her call to the bar cer- emony next month. the three-member panel, said Gold had made many "earnest eff orts" to address his previous misconduct and was unlikely to reoff end but noted there were doubts about his evidence. "His evidence was frequently self-serving, beyond that which was called for in order to put his best foot forward," she wrote. Gold was charged with drug- traffi cking off ences in 1994 after selling drugs to an undercover police offi cer out of his offi ce. He eventually pleaded guilty in 1998 after lengthy investigations into his fi tness to stand trial. He was released in June 1999 after serving 13 months of a 39-month sentence and was dis- barred shortly after. According to the decision, Gold met criminals through apartment buildings he owned in the 1990s and hoped to make as much from drugs as he had from real estate. "I didn't know anything about drugs or drug dealing and I still don't know why I even got in- volved with those people," Gold told a law society investigator in March 2008. "Obviously, I thought I could make millions of dollars like they do on TV and that was a big part of it." But the panel found much of his evidence on his criminal activities was vague. Members were also troubled by his non- criminal misconduct towards clients. Last-minute repayments to the law society's compensa- tion fund stemmed from his de- sire to get licensed rather than remorse, the panel found. CHOOSE FROM CANADA'S TOP MEDIATORS AND ARBITRATORS

• Cover
• Second Chance
• Expert Immunity
• Focus On Criminal Law