Law Times

Page 8 May 12, 2014 • Law TiMes www.lawtimesnews.com Life after retirement Have you planned for your law firm's succession? By marG. Bruineman For Law Times hen it came time for his father to retire, lawyer Ian Hull knew his firm needed a solid plan. e firm would still carry the name Hull & Hull LLP but would soon have just one Hull at the helm. Hull was called to the bar in 1990 and started practising with his dad, Rodney, who was working as a sole practitioner until that point. e younger Hull first joined as an associate and the two later developed a partnership. Hull is thankful his father gave him plenty of notice and wanted to make the transition, which included a pay- out of his capital, smooth for everyone. "I had a willing partner who wanted to exit properly," says Hull, adding that even with two years notice, having a partner retire from a small firm isn't an easy proposition. "A small firm can't sustain an immediate capital payout." e senior Hull agreed to have his capital investment in the firm returned to him over time. Meanwhile, the young- er Hull began to develop a new partnership agreement that spelled out the payment of capital over five years. He continued with the firm and developed the business further to now include four partners. Hull considers himself fortunate in that the entire transaction was friendly and accommodated both of their needs. As a result of the experience, he learned that a small firm should include three ba- sic aspects in its operations: • An exit strategy in the partnership agreement. • Health insurance providing for urgent funding to allow the firm to pay out some of the capital to a partner's family if necessary. • at all partners should have powers of attorney and wills. e senior Hull emphasized to his son that developing a partnership wasn't so much about establishing a firm as it was about determining exit options. "It's really what all small-business own- ers should be doing," says Hull. Hull was able to use his own experience when he sat on a Law Society of Upper Canada committee looking to develop a tool kit for succession planning and set up exit strategies for sole practices, small firms, and professional corporations. e result was a contingency planning guide for lawyers released last June that's avail- able online. Succession planning is a significant concern in the legal profession given the older demographics in many provinces. Lawyers, like other businesspeople, oen don't have a succession plan and, surpris- ingly, some also don't have wills and pow- ers of attorney. e problem is even more significant for sole practitioners who may not have the time to look into the future of their business. But these are the lawyers who are most at risk should something happen to them, says lawyer Michael Litchfield. If sole practitioners don't start plan- ning the future of their business early enough, they may well have to rely upon a contingency plan. One of the areas those working on ac- cess to justice issues have identified is the lack of movement of lawyers to smaller communities. So a lawyer working alone has few options when it comes to retire- ment, particularly in a smaller commu- nity. As a result, planning and looking for a successor should begin early. "I've actually met very few sole practi- tioners who have succession plans," says Litchfield, a management consultant and managing director of inklab Consult- ing Inc. "My recommendation is always to set up a plan. It doesn't have to be difficult. It can be a relatively simple process." Without a successor, the law society becomes responsible for appointing a caretaker should something happen to the lawyer. It can be a costly situation. ere are options for lawyers work- ing on their own who are looking to retire, Litchfield notes. Merging with an existing firm in the lawyer's final years of practice en- sures a natural form of succession. With the current trend of law firm mergers among both small and large practices, it can be a good move for a lawyer considering retirement in the not-too-distant future. ere are also firms looking to grow by transitioning existing practices into theirs. "Another successful succession strategy is to hire a junior lawyer," says Litchfield. e idea would be to transition the new lawyer into the firm as a partner, much as Hull did. Doing so ensures the continuity of legal services. It's a good strategy, but Litchfield suggests having the younger lawyer in- volved in all deals prior to the retirement of the senior practitioner. If that doesn't happen, a business that dealt exclusively with the senior lawyer may not want to sud- denly work with a new person and may consider taking the work elsewhere. ere's also a moral obligation in- volved in ensuring the continuation of legal services in small communities. In some communities, there may not be any other access to a lawyer nearby. at lawyer, of course, can only represent one side. In the event of a marital dispute, for instance, the first one to secure counsel gets the local option, a situation that can leave the other party having to travel great distances to access legal services. Practitioners may consider selling, but Litchfield has found little value there be- cause the worth of a sole practice general- ly relates to the personality of the lawyer. e fourth option is to wind things up and shut the doors. "You can always wind down your prac- tice. It's difficult," says Litchfield. LT Ian Hull had an advantage in that the lawyer leaving his firm was his father. Focus on Running Your Practice CANADA'S PRE-EMINENT MAGAZINE FOCUSING ON THE BUSINESS OF LAW Showcasing leading lawyers and valuable legal business information, Lexpert® is the authoritative source for the latest news and information on the business of law in Canada. SUBSCRIBE TO ® $175* for 10 issues/year *plus applicable taxes Lexpert® feature articles examine legal and corporate issues in: ȕ Emerging practice areas and legal business opportunities ȕ Business development initiatives ȕ Recruitment, retention and talent development ȕ Thought leadership and the future of business law and the legal community Available in print, online, digital format and on our blog, Lexpert® magazine connects in-house counsel, law firms and Canada's C-suite with timely and valuable information on key topics in business law. ORDER YOUR COPY! Visit carswell.com or call 416.609.3800 or 1.800.387.5164 LexpertSub_LT_May12_14.indd 1 14-05-06 8:43 AM W

• Cover