Law Times

Law Times • June 2, 2014 Page 3 www.lawtimesnews.com Construction bar worried about retiring master's replacement By yamri Taddese Law Times embers of the con- struction law bar are expressing concern about a potentially "dramatic impact" on construc- tion lien work in Toronto over worries a Superior Court master will be retiring in January without someone named to replace him. Master David Sandler ex- pressed his concerns about the issue in a December 2013 letter he wrote in support of allowing case management masters to work past the age of retirement. e letter was part of submis- sions to the current commission considering masters' pay. Sandler, one of the two remain- ing traditional masters, was able to work part-time doing construc- tion lien work aer he reached the age of 65. But as is the rule, he'll take full retirement next year. "If I was not available to de- vote 87 days a year (just over four months) to assist with this work, the court resources avail- able for construction lien work would seriously suffer and the current one and half construc- tion masters would be seriously overloaded and unable to cope with the incoming work," wrote Sandler. "I predict that a crisis in this area will develop when I am forced to completely retire as of January 2015. e government seems to be unwilling to appoint any more Toronto masters to remedy the shortage of master manpower." With construction work booming in Toronto — "I don't have to tell you how much con- struction activity there has been in Toronto over the last nine years," wrote Sandler — the lack of masters who specialize in the field would be very problematic, says Anna Esposito, a certified specialist in construction law at Pallett Valo LLP. "Construction is a different animal," she says. "e proce- dures are different, so if you don't do it exactly correctly, it doesn't work. So having that specialized court that knows what they're doing to help you through that mill is wonderful." Construction liens — claims made by contractors or others against a property — fall under the Construction Lien Act. Part of the act's purpose is to expedite these oen-complex claims in- volving multiple parties. Esposito worries that if there aren't enough masters to do con- struction lien work, the task will fall to judges of the Superior Court who already have a full docket. According to Sandler, one part- time and two full-time masters used to do construction lien work until the backlog of civil motions began requiring some of them to take up a different job. "Very recently, the chief jus- tice and the Toronto regional se- nior justice have required one of the two full-time construction lien masters (Master [Charles] Wiebe) to devote half his time to bankruptcy work so that Master [Donald] Short, who, (along with Master [May] Jean), was doing bankruptcy work full-time for the last year, could be reassigned back to deal with the huge back- log of civil motions work," wrote Sandler. is meant only Master Carol Albert and himself were available to do construction lien work, he noted. It would be "a crying shame" to lose the expertise of construc- tion lien masters, says Esposito, who notes they not only ad- judicate complex matters but also manage cases in a way that speeds up the process. ey fo- cus the parties and narrow down the issues even in cases involving multiple parties, she says. "To those of us who practise construction lien, it makes all the difference." Construction lien work is ex- tremely time sensitive, says Da- vis LLP partner Howard Krupat. He notes construction projects may come to a halt until the par- ties resolve a dispute. "Construction liens can have a dramatic impact on projects themselves," he says. "When a construction lien is registered, it has the potential to freeze the flow of funds even when the lien is relatively small com- pared to the size of the project. So those construction lien issues need to be addressed in real time. We need to be able to deal with lien rights immediately." Delayed liens could therefore trigger a domino of interruptions in the construction industry, Krupat adds. So far, he says he hasn't expe- rienced difficulty in bringing cases to a close even though getting trial dates can be challenging. But if Sandler retires with- out a replacement, "this change could have a pretty significant impact," he says. "If the resources were to be changed and if there were only one or one-half masters avail- able, that would have a dramatic impact," he adds. Esposito, who has been part of the construction bar for 26 years, says it's hard to imagine the courts functioning with fewer resources than they have right now. "It's getting really worse," she says. "At no time have the resources been as strained as they are right now, so I can't conceive also los- ing the supernumerary hours that Master Sandler gives." Resources were strained even before master Julian Polika's retire- ment last year, Esposito says. "I can't begin to imagine how the volume of construction work will be handled aer Master Sandler's full retirement." She adds: "If the intention is to completely phase out con- struction lien masters, if you want the dedicated construction lien work to no longer exist, that would be a shame. at would be a crying shame." In response to the concerns, Ministry of the Attorney Gener- al spokesman Brendan Crawley noted it's the chief justice of the Superior Court who oversees the assignment of judicial duties. In addition, he said Toronto's regional senior judge, Justice Geoffrey Morawetz, is examining the scheduling of construction lien matters as part of a broader review of civil cases in Toronto. ere's currently no delay in scheduling construction lien matters, he said. LT NEWS LIVE EVENTS DESIGNED FOR CORPORATIONS AND LAW FIRMS Thomson Reuters Legal Executive Institute is the leading provider of CLE events for the legal industry. Below you'll find upcoming live conferences that might be of interest to you and your team. You can register for yourself and any members of your department. Registration can be applied to anyone in your company – a different person could attend each event. Drafting Clearer Contracts September 11 – Boston, MA October 9 – Minneapolis, MN October 30– Washington DC November 6 – New York , NY Decmeber 11 – San Francisco, CA $895 Cloud Computing: A Practical Approach September 17 – New York, NY $795 DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE Individual Discount – Receive 15% off any individual program. Use promo code 15CORPORATE at checkout. Group Discounts – We have great group discounts available for you and your colleagues. Call 1-800-308-1700 for more information or to register. The more events you purchase, the more you save: ȕ1VSDIBTFSFHJTUSBUJPOTHFUPGG ȕ1VSDIBTFSFHJTUSBUJPOTHFUPGG 2014 Corporate Whistleblowing Forum September 30 - New York $595 The 2014 Thomson Reuters Supply Chain Sustainability Summit October 15 – New York , NY $795 2 WAYS TO REGISTER westlegaledcenter.com 2 1.800.308.1700 1 TR-Legal_LT_June2_14.indd 1 14-05-27 1:30 PM M Justicia celebrated Borden Ladner Gervais LLP partner Lynn McGrade (centre) joined Kirby Chown (left) and Carrie Mandel, the two co-authors of the book Breaking Though: Tales from the Top Canadian Women General Counsel, at a Law Society of Upper Canada event on Wednesday. They spoke at the law society's symposium on the Justicia project, an event attended by about 200 lawyers who participated in vari- ous talks on topics such as finding a mentor, setting goals, and maintaining a practice while on maternity leave. Photo: Bruce Laregina

• Cover