Law Times

Page 4 SePtember 29, 2014 • Law Times www.lawtimesnews.com Lawyer admits records a 'disaster,' apologizes for bilking LAO YaMri taddeSe Law Times lawyer found guilty of charging Legal Aid Ontario for work he didn't do told a Law Society of Upper Canada hear- ing panel his "sloppy record keeping" and his chaotic life due to his addiction to alcohol are to blame for his actions. At his penalty hearing on Sept. 18, William Kennedy of Grand Bend, Ont., disputed as- sertions by law society counsel that he deliberately treated LAO like "a cash machine." He told the panel he didn't keep a record of the time he spent on LAO files and that he used "his best estimates" to charge the organization. He also blamed his alcohol abuse for of- ten clouding his estimates and memory of the work. A hearing panel found Kennedy guilty in June of billing LAO for non-existent trials, court dates, and criminal charges. He has admitted to those allegations in an agreed statement of facts. "My practices of keeping re- cords were irresponsible. They were a disaster," he said during his testimony earlier this month. Asked what care he took to ensure the accuracy of his LAO dockets, he responded: "Very little." Kennedy appeared visibly un- comfortable during cross-exam- ination by law society discipline counsel Elaine Strosberg, who argued his improper billing prac- tices were intentional. "I'm going to suggest that your improper billing was deliberate. You billed the tariff maximums or close to them because legal aid would pay them," she said. "You knew what the maxi- mum was and you just filled in the blanks," she added. But Kennedy insisted what he did was "improper, reckless, sloppy, unprofessional" but "it was not intentional." He exhaled heavily through his responses and once asked for a break dur- ing Strosberg's questions. Strosberg noted Kennedy had obtained an adjournment in October to allow him to go to rehabilitation but suggested he still hadn't taken that step. "In Oc- tober last year, he said he was out the door on his way to rehab and he wasn't," she said. "He comes before [the hearing panel] today with the same problems and he has not dealt with them." For his part, Kennedy said he didn't have the money he needed to go to rehabilitation and later decided he'd seek counselling in- stead. But this summer had been a "wake-up call," he said, noting he has realized he wouldn't resolve his significant alcohol problems through counselling alone. Three out of his four children don't talk to him, said Kennedy, adding he has had a number of health issues throughout the year. "I didn't really fully admit I have a significant problem until recently," he said. If allowed to keep his licence, Kennedy said he intends to pay LAO the nearly $12,000 he owes the organization. He also apolo- gized to the panel, the public, and the law society for his actions. "I am very sorry for this proceed- ing, that my conduct led to this proceeding. It will never happen again," he said. He added: "These monies shouldn't go to reckless profes- sionals like myself. I am a dis- grace in the jurisdictions in which I practise." Kennedy had overbilled LAO by $25,000, an amount based on the 20 investigated files out of 107 certificates he had handled. Of that amount, LAO has recovered about $13,000 of its losses by claw- ing back funds owed to Kennedy. The organization says it doesn't have the resources to look into all of the 107 cases he worked on. When LAO discovered is- sues with Kennedy's billings, it asked him for detailed accounts. But he told the hearing panel the detailed accounts were also full of information fetched from his memory. "Instead of saying to legal aid, 'I don't have [the detailed ac- counts],' you recreated them from thin air," said Strosberg. She added: "He made it all up. It was all fiction." Lawyer Brian Radnoff, who's representing Kennedy on a pro bono basis, pointed out in- stances in which his client didn't charge LAO for work he did do. When it comes to charging LAO for contested trials that didn't happen, one of the improper ac- tions Kennedy has admitted to, the lawyer said he was under the impression that he could bill the organization for his preparation for the proceedings even though they didn't go ahead. The hearing panel, chaired by Barbara Murchie, asked if it could — in the hypothetical scenario that it found Kennedy didn't de- liberately overbill LAO — sus- pend him indefinitely until he returns from rehabilitation and proves he's a changed man. Strosberg said the panel had discretion to make that finding but pointed out Kennedy hadn't presented a medical report to prove his addiction had caused his misconduct. "We're not a time machine. We don't know if he had alco- holism in 2005," she said. "How can you know? He has every reason to give you a self-serving version of events." The panel has reserved its de- cision. LT NEWS LEXPERT LEGAL EDUCATION SEMINARS FALL 2014 SCHEDULE NEW PROCUREMENT: CRITICAL DEVELOPMENTS FROM PROCESS TO PRACTICE Toronto • October 21, 2014 REVOLUTIONARY PAYMENT SOLUTIONS 2014 & BEYOND: LEGAL & REGULATORY COMPLIANCE PRIMER Toronto • October 29, 2014 THE COMPLETE GUIDE TO DEFENSE & SECURITY PROCUREMENT 2014 & BEYOND: NAVIGATING CANADA'S FAST CHANGING LANDSCAPE Toronto • November 6, 2014 6TH ANNUAL ABORIGINAL LAW: CONSULTATION AND OTHER EMERGING ISSUES Calgary • December 2, 2014 Toronto • December 9, 2014 7TH ANNUAL ADVERTISING LAW: BEYOND THE CASL WALLS Toronto • December 2, 2014 CONDUCTING EFFECTIVE WORKPLACE INVESTIGATIONS: WHEN IGNORANCE ISN'T BLISS Toronto • December 3, 2014 ANTI-BRIBERY AND CORRUPTION COMPLIANCE: COPING WITH THE ONSLAUGHT Calgary • December 8, 2014 Toronto • December 11, 2014 INFORMATION PRIVACY AND DATA PROTECTION Toronto • November 27, 2014 Vancouver • December 2, 2014 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE 2014: CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN SPECIAL SITUATIONS Toronto • December 4, 2014 Calgary • December 8, 2014 MANAGING RISK IN THE MINING SECTOR – PRACTICAL STRATEGIES FOR SUCCESSFUL OUTCOMES Toronto • November 20, 2014 THE LIFE CYCLE OF PHARMACEUTICALS – ADDING VALUE AT EACH STAGE Toronto • November 4, 2014 DEALING WITH THE LEASE: STATE OF THE UNION! TODAY'S TOP TEN LEASE ISSUES PLUS THE FRANCHISE TRIANGLE Toronto • November 26, 2014 REGISTER ONLINE www.lexpert.ca/cpdcentre WEBCAST OPTION AVAILABLE! For more information or to register, please contact Lexpert® Events at 1-877-298-5868 or e-mail: register@lexpert.ca LEXC1238_Lexpert course ad for fall_7.875x6.5.indd 1 14-07-29 11:20 AM Learn the nuts and bolts of setting up and running your own practice in Going It Alone: A Start-Up Guide for the Sole Practitioner, Second Edition. This well-organized, step-by-step book has been updated and substantially revised and contains must-know information for opening your own solo practice. The Second Edition • Walks you through every step towards your goal of being a sole practitioner • Shares helpful tips and strategies in a concise, informal, easy-to-read tone • Provides short checklists of materials or resources needed to efficiently set up and run your firm • Discusses how to maintain your mental health, not just your professional standards New Edition Going It Alone: A Start-Up Guide for the Sole Practitioner, Second Edition Wendy E. Oughtred The step-by-step guide to opening your own law practice Order # 804722-65203 $75 Softcover approx. 170 pages September 2014 978-0-88804-722-9 Shipping and handling are extra. Price subject to change without notice and subject to applicable taxes. 00222RY-A45596 Available risk-free for 30 days Order online: www.carswell.com Call Toll-Free: 1-800-387-5164 In Toronto: 416-609-3800 A

• Cover