Law Times

Page 10 December 8, 2014 • Law Times www.lawtimesnews.com FOCUS New book features lawyers' accounts of their biggest cases By Glenn kauTh Law Times hroughout his career as a law- yer, Richard Wolson has heard the slamming of jail doors on his many visits to clients in prison. But while he's well familiar with jails, the thought of one man spending years behind bars continues to affect him. "I can't really imagine what it would be like for a man wrongfully charged, wrong- fully convicted, and wrongfully sentenced to life in prison," said Wolson. "That man was Thomas Sophonow." Sophonow's case is among the stories told by 20 high-profile defence lawyers in the new book Tough Crimes: True Cases by Top Canadian Criminal Lawyers. At a late November launch for the book at the Spoke Club in Toronto, Wolson talked about his work as commission counsel for the inquiry into Sophonow's wrong- ful conviction, a case he called a "terrible travesty of justice." The case against Sophonow in the 1981 killing of Barbara Stoppel hinged, he noted, on things such as jailhouse informants, one of whom had a perjury conviction. "The evidence was unbeliev- able," he said, noting how "tunnel vision" was a key factor in the case that resulted in Sophonow spending 45 months in jail. "From start to finish when I became in- volved in the inquiry, I could see that this was a perfect storm for wrongful convic- tion. Sophonow never had a chance," he told the audience at the book launch. The book tells the stories of some of Can- ada's biggest crimes, including the Paul Ber- nardo rape and murder cases and Toronto's infamous shoeshine boy murder in the 1970s. It features firsthand accounts by some of Canada's top criminal defence lawyers: Edward Greenspan, who uses a pseudonym to tell the story of his client, Tom James; John Rosen, who describes the Bernardo case; Richard Peck, who discusses reasonable doubt in the Air India matter; Brian Beresh, who writes about the defence of Larry Fisher; and Marie Henein, a lawyer now in the spot- light for defending Jian Ghomeshi but who in Tough Crimes talks about how seconds mattered in one of her earlier big cases involving former attorney gen- eral Michael Bryant. Christopher Evans, a veteran defence counsel and one of the editors of the book along with Lorene Shyba, says the goal was to get the defence lawyers to write about the cases that still haunt them. "These were from the heart. 'I still think of this case. It will never leave me,'" he says in describing the tone of the book. "There are cases that come back to haunt me," says Evans, who notes he still sometimes wakes up thinking about them. He himself wrote a chapter in the book about weighing the moralities of victimless crimes in light of his defence of fugitive tax scoff law Charles Vernon Myers in the 1980s. Noting the uniqueness of having prominent defence lawyers describe their biggest cases from a first-person stand- point, he says: "I think it demonstrates that there's a tremendous amount of emotional involvement." "How often do the lawyers who prosecuted or defended a case actually write about it?" he asks, noting the book counters the notion of the detached de- fence lawyer who remains emotionally distant from cases. But for Rosen, Bernardo's case isn't the one that affected him the most. "This case does not haunt me," he says, noting it was merely the one that was the biggest from a media perspective. "He said [to write] anything you want to do, so he gave me no direction," Rosen says of his instructions from Evans when he agreed to write a chapter. But in his chapter, Rosen does make it clear the horrific case had a significant im- pact on him. In writing about watching the notorious videotapes of Bernardo's rapes, he said: "Much has been writ- ten about the videotapes, the failure of police to find them, and the hor- rific nature of their contents. But nothing has ever been said about the impact of the tapes on the lawyers." He continued: "In truth, though, the images depicted shook me to the core. At one point, I needed to stop and excuse myself for a few moments. The images were deeply disturbing and the implications were obvious. How was I going to defend this case in the face of these tapes?" A key theme in the book is the in- tegrity of the criminal justice process and the important role of defence lawyers in upholding it, ensuring the rights of their clients, and holding the state to account. As Rosen noted in the book, lots of people on the street recognized him from his role in defending one of Canada's most hated criminals, but none of them were hostile. "No one ut- tered an unkind word. Perhaps it was their way of thanking me for my efforts or, more broadly, for validating and recognizing my role in the criminal justice system that all Canadians value. In other words, they recognized that we all had a stake in ensuring a fair trial and a just outcome for everyone. Even Paul Bernardo agreed." At the book launch, Wolson made refer- ence to similar themes as he warned about the continuing risk of wrongful convic- tions. "The story of Tom Sophonow is a story for everyone in the criminal justice system. If we're not careful, it can happen again without question." LT Get practical legal know-how for every stage of your investigation Available risk-free for 30 days Order online: www.carswell.com Call Toll-Free: 1-800-387-5164 In Toronto: 416-609-3800 Whether you are a criminal or a regulatory investigator, this handbook will give you the solid grounding in legal principles, best practices and collaborative techniques that will help you make effective decisions at every stage of your case. This user-friendly handbook contains the practical legal information you'll rely on every day. You'll find expert guidance on taking notes, drafting search warrants, wiretaps, and other applications for judicial investigative authorization. You'll learn how to draft solid charges, prepare a compelling prosecution brief, and gather together a complete disclosure package that will stand up to the most vigorous challenges at trial and on appeal. You'll also find real-life examples of the right and wrong way to conduct investigations. Insightful investigator/prosecutor Q&As throughout the book will clarify challenging areas of the law. And convenient checklists make this book an invaluable, time-saving resource in the field. New in this edition • Covers the impact of the Internet and information communication technology on investigative techniques, offences, and privacy • Includes new forms of offences, investigative techniques, and privacy concerns • Identifies the challenges created by the online world and offers solutions for criminal and regulatory investigators • Includes the latest developments in legislation and case law Order # 986377-65203 $73 Softcover approx. 700 pages July 2014 978-0-7798-6377-8 Shipping and handling are extra. Price(s) subject to change without notice and subject to applicable taxes. 00223DN-A45879 New Edition The Investigator's Legal Handbook, Second Edition Gordon Scott Campbell T Tough Crimes features firsthand accounts from 20 prominent defence lawyers.

• Cover