The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://digital.lawtimesnews.com/i/50767
Law timeS • September 20, 2010 NEWS PAGE 5 New crime bills on government agenda BY TIM NAUMETZ For Law Times OTTAWA — Justice Minister Rob Nicholson is maintaining his seemingly inexhaustible at- tacks against what the Conser- vatives perceive as weaknesses in Canada's justice system with new crime bills this fall on top of nine pieces of legislation that remained when Parliament adjourned for the summer. Th e agenda continues the am- bitious pace Nicholson has main- tained since he assumed the post in January 2007. It includes new legislation to increase penalties for sexual of- fences against children and an as- yet undefi ned "additional action" to address the "disturbing" num- ber of unsolved cases of murdered and missing aboriginal women, according to Nicholson's press secretary Pamela Stephens. But defence lawyers and op- position critics insist many of the tough changes he has brought in so far, including more manda- tory minimum sentences and other moves that will increase incarceration rates and force the government to build new pris- ons, have taken the country in the wrong direction. At the same time, an NDP MP says the government can expect trouble on one of Nichol- son's signature legislative chang- es: signifi cant amendments to toughen up the Youth Criminal Justice Act that were still before the House of Commons justice committee when Parliament ad- journed nearly 12 weeks ago. "Complex problems are not solved by simple solutions," says Ottawa defence lawyer Norm Boxall, a vice president of the Criminal Lawyers' Association. "For sure, there are issues of social matters, of crime, these are issues that we need to address, but the simple solution that suddenly we're going to be tough on it to make it go away doesn't work." Joseph Di Luca, another CLA vice president who chairs its leg- islation committee, agrees. He notes that in the United States, where increased incarceration rates and minimum sentences have been the norm for more than a decade, crime has contin- ued to rise at a higher rate than in Canada. Nicholson intends to table, over and above his bill to hike penalties for sexual crimes against children and his measure aimed at the unsolved murders and disappearances of hundreds of aboriginal women, legislation to give police "investigative powers for the 21st century," along with changes to reduce the number of mega-trials in organized crime prosecutions. Th ose moves were news to Joe Comartin, the Windsor, Ont., NDP MP and lawyer who has been one of Nicholson's toughest opponents as the array of tough-on-crime bills has tak- en its stormy path through the Commons and Senate. Comar- tin tells Law Times he had heard nothing about them prior to CLL ad - new.indd 1 Inside you will find: • an up-to-date alphabetical listing of more than 57,000 barristers, solicitors and Quebec notaries, corporate counsel, law firms and judges in Canada; • contact information for the Supreme Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada, Federal Cabinet Ministers, departments, boards, commissions and Crown corporations; • legal and government contact information related to each province for the Courts of Appeal, Supreme Courts, County and District Courts, Provincial Courts, law societies, law schools, Legal Aid, and other law-related offices of importance. More than a phone book Hardbound • Published February each year • On subscription $141 • P/C 0600140999 One-time purchase $157 • P/C 0600010999 • ISSN 0084-8573 CD-ROM • On subscription $214 • P/C 0600260999 One-time purchase $229 • P/C 0600210000 their disclosure through Nich- olson's press secretary last week. He suspects that, other than the bid to deal with the puzzling and tragic mystery of missing and murdered aboriginal women over the past decade, the other changes are among issues that have arisen at the justice com- mittee over the last year. "I'm not sure how ambitious this is. It sounds like a lot of stuff we've already covered," says Comartin, speculating that the legislation targeting drawn-out trials involved in large organized crime investigations may deal with diffi culties complying with disclosure requirements as police accumulate massive volumes of evidence through electronic wire- taps and the related data fi les cre- ated through modern informa- tion technology. Comartin says Liberal MPs, who supported the government during parliamentary votes earlier this year on many of the crime bills to avoid an election the party was unprepared to fi ght, have privately indicated they may take a stand on the amendments dealing with youth crime. Th e bill establishes deterrence and denunciation as sentencing prin- ciples similar to the adult crimi- nal justice system and requires the Crown to consider the possibility of seeking an adult sentence for off enders as young as 14 who have been convicted of murder, attempted murder, manslaughter or aggravated sexual assault. "Th e Liberals are making noises that they're going to stand up," Comartin says. "Th ere has been some discussion amongst all three [opposition parties] that maybe the best thing would be to just defeat it and tell the gov- ernment to go back and start all over again." Th e bills remaining from the winter and spring sittings include legislation that would eliminate conditional sentenc- es, or house arrest, for serious crimes; remove the so-called faint-hope clause that allows application for early parole dur- ing life sentences for murder or second-degree murder; intro- duce mandatory minimums for serious drug crimes; bring in a 20-plus years ago when they embarked on a fruitless war on drugs. Instead of making a no- ticeable dent in the drug trade and related crimes, they ended up with a nation of people in jail and an increasing crime rate." Th e Canadian Bar Associa- 'I think we are witnessing an unfortunate shift in criminal justice philosophy,' says Joseph Di Luca. requirement for Internet service providers to report child por- nography; and enact tougher sentences for auto theft. "I think we are witnessing an unfortunate shift in criminal jus- tice philosophy," Di Luca says. "Instead of learning the valuable lessons from our U.S. counter- parts, we are marching down the same path they took some tion declined to comment on Nicholson's fall plans, but the organization has already added its voice in opposition to a gov- ernment measure that could spell trouble for Prime Minister Stephen Harper once Parliament resumes: the cancellation of the mandatory long form of the 2011 national census. In a July letter to Industry Minister Tony Clement, Kevin Carroll, the CBA's president at the time, said the association has "serious concerns" about the move because census data is used extensively in personal in- jury claims. "Th e information is particularly important in major loss cases involving injured chil- dren and is the source of much of the consensus of opinion among experts on quantum loss of future earnings." LT For a 30-day, no risk evaluation call 1.800.565.6967 Canada Law Book, a Thomson Reuters business. Prices subject to change without notice, to applicable taxes and shipping and handling. www.lawtimesnews.com 8/19/10 5:09:43 PM