Law Times

PAGE 4 NEWS February 13, 2012 • Law Times Lawyers call for reforms to bonding rules BY MICHAEL McKIERNAN Law Times I t's time to bring Ontario's bond- ing requirements on estate trust- ees into the 21st century, trusts and estates lawyers say. The province's Estates Act requires trustees to post a bond worth double the value of the estate when the will names an executor who lives outside the Commonwealth. In addition, Ontario residents seeking appoint- ment must post bonds when the will doesn't name them as trustees or the deceased left no will at all. "The current provisions are really anachronistic. They come from a past where there isn't prop- er consideration being given to what is the purpose of the bond and who we are trying to protect," says Brian Schnurr, a partner with RELIABLE TAX EXPERTISE FOR NON-TAX LAWYERS NEW EDITION THE LAWYER'S GUIDE TO INCOME TAX AND GST/HST 2011 DAVID M. SHERMAN, B.A., LL.B, LL.M. Author David M. Sherman provides all the core information a non-tax lawyer needs to effectively handle the tax aspects of clients' affairs. The book also answers the key tax questions on lawyers' fees: When is GST or HST charged? When are the fees deductible to the client? It also includes an overview of the basics of the Canadian personal and corporate tax systems, GST and HST systems, and the tax objection and appeal process. ORDER #982886-65199 $98 Softcover 490 pages September 2010 978-0-7798-2886-9 Annual volumes available on standing order subscription Shipping and handling are extra. Price subject to change without notice and subject to applicable taxes. COMPREHENSIVE CONTENT AND TIME-SAVING FEATURES • Ease of access Separate chapters on Family Law, Litigation, Real Estate, Small Business, Wills and Estates, Employment Law, Intellectual Property and Immigration make it easy to find information relating to your issue • Concise Commentary Clear, straightforward commentary by David M. Sherman, one of Canada's most prolific and respected tax authors • Sidenote Sources Information sources are referenced in side notes, listing statutory references, government publications and case law "Sherman has the gift of distilling a maze of impenetrable tax laws into a logical, readable format. Indispensable tool for understanding GST and tax law." Max Berger, Barrister & Solicitor • Appendices and Tables Detailed tax tables providing current tax rate information, reference to other key sources, a Table of Cases and a Table of Statutory References • Detailed Topical Index A time-saving feature that provides quick access to essential information AVAILABLE RISK-FREE FOR 30 DAYS Order online at www.carswell.com Call Toll-Free: 1-800-387-5164 In Toronto: 416-609-3800 Toronto estate litigators Schnurr Kirsh Schnurr Oelbaum Tator LLP. "If there's a foreign executor in Buffalo, they have to be bonded, but if it's a foreign executor who lives in Tasmania, they don't because it's in Australia and it's part of the British Commonwealth. That just makes no sense whatsoever." As long ago as 1991, the Ontario Law Reform Commission recom- mended changes to the require- ments and in April 2010, the Ontario Bar Association revived the cause by writing to the province's attorney general with suggestions for modernization. The OBA proposal would elim- inate the general bonding require- ment for trustees not named in a will and wouldn't require a bond when at least one trustee is res- ident in Ontario. However, the bonding would remain in place when vulnerable beneficiaries such as minors or mentally inca- pable people are involved. Bonds protect beneficiaries and creditors from negligence or misappropriation by the trust- ee, but Vincent De Angelis, a Markham, Ont., trusts and estates lawyer who was involved in craft- ing the OBA submission, says the current rules go over the top in achieving that aim. "Where there's no special circumstances such as minors involved, there's no reason why choosing a trusted family member from outside the Commonwealth should create undue difficulty for one's beneficiaries," he says. "This proposal will allow a trusted family member to be cho- sen by a testator or by a court as long as there is also an Ontario trustee. Given the law of fiduciary duty, combined with joint and sev- eral liability, the existence of an Ontario trustee will negate the enforceability concerns that may exist with a non-resident trustee." According to the OBA submis- Twelfth Annual AWARDS OF DISTINCTIONPresentation Ceremony and Reception Recognizing MR. JUSTICE IAN C. BINNIE THE HONOURABLE Th ursday, March 1, 2012 Reception – 5:30 p.m. & Presentation – 6:30 p.m. One King West, Grand Banking Hall, 1 King St. W., Toronto Price $100 (HST incl.) per person or $950 (HST incl.) for a package of 10 tickets To purchase tickets please contact: T.Law_LT_Feb13_12.indd 1 416-327-5700 or jrataiclang@tlaonline.ca www.lawtimesnews.com 12-02-07 4:13 PM sion, the trend in other jurisdictions, including the United Kingdom, New Zealand, and various U.S. states, has been a move away from general bonding requirements. The law reform commission identified the same trend in its 1991 report. Amy Cull, an associate at Toronto's Whaley Estate Litigation, says a bond can be an onerous proposition for a trustee, especially when a large estate is involved. "If you get a large estate with assets in the range of $1 million and an estate trustee with assets of $20,000, you're going to have dif- ficulty getting a bond," says Cull. "In one case, we've had clients having to mortgage their property." Cull notes there are few insur- ance companies that will issue bonds, and most have policies that prevent them from insuring trustees outside North America. That cre- ates problems for non-Common- wealth trustees who don't live in the United States. They represent a growing demographic in Ontario. "Given the multicultural make- up of the province and immigra- tion from countries in Asia and Africa, it's more and more likely you'll have family members acting as trustees who are not from the Commonwealth, which is going There are very few insurance companies that will issue bonds, says Amy Cull. to increase the pressure to change the bonding requirements," says De Angelis. For those who struggle in vain to get a bond, the difficulty of getting a court to dispense with the require- ment compounds their problems. The Estates Act gives judges dis- cretion to exempt applicants from the bonding requirements under special circumstances. But the leg- islation is silent on what that might mean and a 2008 decision sets a high standard for dispensation. In Henderson (Re), Ontario Superior Court Justice David Brown said applicants must file a detailed affidavit with corroborat- ing evidence about the value and debts of the estate as well as exten- sive information on the beneficia- ries, creditors, and deceased. "The court generally will err on the side of requiring the bond," says Schnurr. "Even if the benefi- ciaries are adults and they all say they don't want the expense of a bond to be incurred and they know and trust the estate trustee, often that's not enough for the court to dispense with it." De Angelis hopes the OBA's proposed new rules will reduce the burden on trustees by making it easier for them to avoid court. "It'll also free up judicial resources for other work and improve the efficiency of the administration of justice, espe- cially since cost-containment measures have become crucial in the justice system," he says. Schnurr says the lack of move- ment on the issue since 1991 may be due in part to the scale of the shift the change would represent. "There's probably also a con- cern that if we tinker with this and reduce the number of circum- stances where a bond is required, we may be exposing ourselves to some criticism because there may be examples in the future where beneficiaries have been ripped off by the trustee that would have been covered by bonds in the past," he says. But De Angelis says the govern- ment's response has been encour- aging. He also notes the OBA has been busy responding to the issues raised. "We do have a draft in the works, which we will submit shortly, so there is some traction," he says. "I think the provincial election contributed to the delay somewhat and now that the elec- tion is over, we're looking to see some more progress." LT

• Cover