Law Times

Page 12 SePTeMBeR 28, 2015 • LaW TIMeS www.lawtimesnews.com Companies responding to copyright infringement in creative ways BY YAMRI TADDESE Law Times A s technology enables copyright infringe- ments on a massive scale, some companies have adopted innovative ways of dealing with them. Take, for example, how Hasbro Inc. is handling fans who want to use its My Little Pony brand in various ways. Although My Little Pony is a children's TV show, it has an unexpected fan base among adult men fascinated with the ani- mation and characters. When these fans, nicknamed Bronies, created an online video game based on My Little Pony, Hasbro quickly shut it down, says Bereskin & Parr LLP partner Noel Courage. But the company relented in another way. "One thing they did agree to do is Hasbro is letting people print ponies with a 3D printer, and you can order them through an online store, which is a very co-operative way to do it," says Courage. "So Hasbro is giving up a little bit of control creatively, but they're still trying to maintain strong control of their brand, which is kind of what you have to do as a trademark owner." In an era of the shared econo- my, that's one of the ways compa- nies are trying to deal with the il- legal proliferation of their brands in the public domain while still engaging their fans, says Courage. "It's an interesting way of do- ing business and dealing with in- fringement as opposed to trying to shut everybody down," he adds. "Particularly with a strong fan base, it's an innovative way to do things and to work with the fan base and to enable the fan base to do things that are innovative and interesting but still having some control over the situation, too." Stéphane Caron, an intellec- tual property lawyer at Gowling Laf leur Henderson LLP, notes that fan fiction and drawings of characters from shows and books aren't uncommon. His daughter, for example, is an avid illustrator of ponies from My Little Pony. Often, copyright owners don't take an issue with that except when fans monetize their prod- ucts. That's what makes Hasbro's model interesting, says Caron. Select users who design their own ponies and get them deliv- ered through three-dimensional printing service Shapeways Inc. can then sell their product to the general public, he adds. "The challenge that the rights owners face is the fact that with 3D printing, it is now possible to create three-dimensional charac- ters like My Little Pony characters and as the technology becomes increasingly available and cheap, it will be increasingly difficult to control that," he says. When the technology does become ubiquitous, the fact that authorized sellers are available would mitigate illegal printings, he notes. "If there are legitimate, authorized, quality services in parallel, I think that will help the industry cope with those chal- lenges. If the only way for the user to generate his or her own [print- ing] is to do it illegally, then the risk is they will. If they're given an opportunity to do it legally or illegally, at least they have a choice." That's a hard-learned lesson from the music industry over the years, says Caron, suggesting it's better to have a legal business model that can generate revenue and is advantageous to all than trying to stop any and all use of a trademark. The music industry, of course, is a prime example of the impact of large-scale infringements en- abled by the Internet. The indus- try is still trying to figure out how to deal with them and has suffered greatly, says Courage. Recently, however, the indus- try has taken some control over the situation by working with Google Inc. The technology gi- ant now has powerful software that tracks down copyrighted songs on YouTube and places ads on them. The revenue from those ads, which will play ahead of the songs, goes to the actual copyright owner instead of the user who posted the video. The software, called Con- tent ID, is "kind of an interesting and curious tool," says Courage. He recalls a viral incident from two years ago that later involved the software. Alberta's Robert Wilkinson, who was at the time facing arrest for drinking and driving, belted out his rendition of the classic Queen song Bohemian Rhapsody while sitting in the back of an RCMP cruiser. When police sent Wilkinson the video record- ed in the cruiser as evidence in his case, he uploaded it online at the urging of his friends, according to the National Post. Sure enough, the video went viral. "It's a terrible rendition, but there's ad revenue. If you go on that web site, there are ads that pop up with the video so the copyright owner can divert that revenue," says Courage. YouTube gives copyright own- ers a few options once Content ID tracks down their copyright- ed material. They can elect to mute audio on videos that con- tain their song or block a whole video from appearing. They may also track the video's viewership statistics or monetize the video by running ads against it. The idea of collaborating isn't new in the intellectual property field. "People often realize you can make a lot more money by co-operating with other people and licensing out their work," says Courage. "Traditionally, it was all an orderly process where you'd have something available and people would license it from you, negotiate licences. Occa- sionally, a big company would be an infringer or some other competitor would infringe and you would either stop them from using it or you would ne- gotiate a licence with them." As the Internet dramatically increases the number of infring- ers, "now you just can't do that," says Courage, adding the old ways of managing infringements is proving tedious or ineffective. LT FOCUS With more than 1,400 pages of essential legal references, Ontario Lawyer's Phone Book is your best connection to legal services in Ontario. Subscribers can depend on the credibility, accuracy and currency of this directory year after year. More detail and a wider scope of legal contact information for Ontario than any other source: • Over 27,000 lawyers listed • Over 9,000 law firms and corporate offices listed • Fax and telephone numbers, e-mail addresses, office locations and postal codes Includes lists of: • Federal and provincial judges • Federal courts, including a section for federal government departments, boards and commissions • Ontario courts and services, including a section for provincial government ministries, boards and commissions • Small claims courts • The Institute of Law Clerks of Ontario • Miscellaneous services for lawyers Visit carswell.com or call 1.800.387.5164 for a 30-day no-risk evaluation CANADA LAW BOOK ® This text is the first of its kind – designed to provide a comprehensive introduction to the topic and analysis of different policy approaches to green energy. Directed towards environmental law practitioners and those involved in the development of green energy policies, its perspective is Canadian yet, as the international shift towards renewable energy intensifies, our role on the global stage is illuminated. Canadian Green Energy Law and Policy launches at a time when a thorough knowledge of the subject matter is critical. This book offers essential practical guidance on the issues involved in getting these projects organized, approved and built, providing you with a comprehensive overview of the legal and policy frameworks involved – providing context from both sides of the inherent arguments. NEW PUBLICATION CANADIAN GREEN ENERGY LAW AND POLICY FRED D. CASS SPEARHEADING RESPONSIBLE ENERGY POLICY DEVELOPMENT ORDER # 804528 $120 Hardcover approx. 425 pages March 2012 978-0-88804-528-7 AVAILABLE RISK-FREE FOR 30 DAYS Order online at www.carswell.com Call Toll-Free: 1-800-387-5164 In Toronto: 416-609-3800 Shipping and handling are extra. Price subject to change without notice and subject to applicable taxes. Perfectbound Published December each year On subscription $77 One time purchase $80 L88804-677 Multiple copy discounts available. Plus applicable taxes and shipping & handling. (prices subject to change without notice) 2015 ONTARIO LAWYER'S PHONE BOOK THE MOST COMPLETE DIRECTORY OF ONTARIO LAWYERS, LAW FIRMS, JUDGES AND COURTS 'People often realize you can make a lot more money by co-operating with other people and licensing out their work," says Noel Courage.

• Cover