Law Times

Page 10 NOVeMBeR 30, 2015 • LaW TIMeS www.lawtimesnews.com FOCUS Women make mark in male-dominated patent litigation BY JULIUS MELNITZER For Law Times f gender equality is the measuring stick, then Marguerite Ethie r is from Venus and Judith Robin- son is from Mars. It's nothing less than a tale of two veteran patent litiga- tion lawyers, women func- tioning in a male-dominated world. However, when it comes to gender equality, the similarities of their 25 years of experience in the field — they were both called in the early 1990s — may lie only in the practice area they share. Both Ethier, now at Lenc- zner Slaght Royce Smith Griffin LLP in Toronto, and Robinson, who has practised at Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP and its legacy firms, speak favourably of their formative years. Ethier worked in-house from 2000 to 2005, and then joined Lenczner Slaght. She began her career as a summer student at what was then Sim Hughes, an intellectual property boutique. Later, she articled at McCar- thy Tétrault LLP, becoming the firm's first patent litigation part- ner in 1998. "I learned much at these firms, and the experiences so- lidified my desire to be a patent litigator," she recalls. "I was for- tunate to find litigation mentors who encouraged me and who were almost always male." At the time, other female pat- ent litigators were nowhere to be seen. "Women weren't choosing patent law then, as it had been engineering-centric for so many years," Ethier says. "In my first few years, I was often the sole woman in a room full of patent lawyers, experts, or clients, and I never worked with another fe- male patent litigator in my first 10 years." However, as pharma and biotech-related work infiltrated patent practice, women entered patent practice in increasing numbers. By way of example, between 1970 and 2002, women comprised just nine per cent of the winners of the J. Edward Maybee Memorial Prize for the highest overall mark on the pat- ent agents examination. Since 2003, the proportion has risen to 58 per cent. While Ethier finds the trend "encouraging," she isn't sure that the growing numbers have made a real difference. "Have things changed, really changed?" she asks. Not if the off-the-cuff remarks Ethier continues to endure are any indica- tion. They include sug- gestions by some "very successful" lawyers that "women don't have the stamina for all-night cor- porate closing"; comments that "patents are for guys, trademarks are for chicks"; requests from clients to Ethier's male seniors that "your girl go get us some coffee"; and salutations such as "listen, little lady." Ethier has also been ac- cused of being a "bitch," of "whining," and of being an "arrogant, argumentative, and unco-operative" individual. "The role of a patent litigator is to zealously advocate on behalf of our clients," Ethier says. "How- ever, behaviour that in men is considered to be tenacious, per- sistent, and fearless is character- ized as bitchy, whiny, strident, or hysterical in women." To be sure, the demeaning re- marks have diminished over the years — but they have not disap- peared. "Some are almost 25 years old," Ethier says. "But some are within the last two years, and they're always made by men, including judges on some occa- sions." Ethier also believes that the diminution is at least partly at- tributable to her seniority. "The comments are fewer and less specific than when I was a young lawyer, but I have no doubt that they continue to be said about me and especially about my junior colleagues," she says. Her experiences, Ethier observes, are not uncommon among women at the patent liti- gation bar. "Some of my stories pale in comparison to what I have heard perpetrated on others," she says. Robinson has been at Nor- ton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP and its legacy firms since she was called in 1991. She's expe- rienced none of the inequality that plagued Ethier's career and her experience with opposing counsel, clients, and judges is a positive one. "I have always had a respect- ful communication with oppos- ing counsel, and certainly noth- ing that I would ever identify as a gender issue," she says. Robinson believes that firm culture played and continues to play a huge role in her experi- ence. While female patent lit- igators may have been scarce elsewhere, for example, that wasn't the case at her firm. "Ogilvy Renault, where I started, was founded by an IP practitioner and the IP prac- tice was headed by a female litigator," she says. "I always felt supported and encour- aged, and our firm's dispro- portionate number of strong patent litigators probably includes more women than men in that category." But Ethier's supportive years were also marked by support and encouragement at McCarthy. The difference in their experiences with opposing counsel, clients, and judges, Robinson believes, may lie in her firm's established reputation in the IP field. "The firm culture at Ogilvy allowed me to get experience and a reputation quickly," she says. "I think that facilitated things in ways that were not available to other women in the field." Still, Robinson believes that Ethier, whom she calls a "cham- pion of this issue," has a cause that merits attention. "I don't think it's normal to look across the courtroom and see that there are no women on other legal teams," she says. "I also think it unacceptable that just a handful of women appear in the legal directory rankings." As it turns out, Ethier re- mains hopeful. "I do think that the increas- ing number of female patent liti- gators will change the dynamic," she says. Some will say that should have happened long ago. LT CANADIAN LAW LIST 2015 KEEPING PACE WITH THE CHANGING LEGAL COMMUNITY FOR OVER 130 YEARS This is more than a phone book. It is your instant connection to Canada's legal network. With Canadian Law List 2015 you have access to: ȕ an up-to-date alphabetical listing of more than 86,000 barristers, solicitors and Quebec notaries, corporate counsel, law firms and judges across Canada ȕ all contact information supplied for the Supreme Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada, Federal Cabinet Ministers, departments, boards, commissions and Crown Corporations ȕ legal and government contact information related to each province for the Courts of Appeal, Supreme Courts, County and District Courts, Provincial Courts, law societies, law schools, Legal Aid and other important law-related offices THE LATEST CONTACT INFORMATION IN A USER- FRIENDLY FORMAT THAT IS BEYOND TRADITIONAL LISTINGS Continually updated by a dedicated team of professionals, Canadian Law List includes value added features such as: ȕ last name first identification in the federal and provincial listings ȕ separate section of corporate law departments for more than 1,300 companies ȕ professional cards of prominent Canadian law firms ȕ International Agency Referral Cards )BSECPVOEȕ1VCMJTIFE'FCSVBSZ FBDIZFBSȕ- ȕOOTVCTDSJQUJPO ȕOOFUJNFQVSDIBTF MVMUJQMFDPQZEJTDPVOUTBWBJMBCMF 1MVTTIJQQJOHIBOEMJOH BOEBQQMJDBCMFUBYFT ORDER YOUR COPY TODAY! Call 1.800.387.5164 or visit www.carswell.com Untitled-1 1 2015-11-11 1:59 PM I 'I also think it unacceptable that just a handful of women appear in the legal directory rankings,' says Judith Robinson 'Have things changed, really changed?' asks Marguerite Ethier. Check out lawtimesnews.com for insight from our regular online columnists Monica Goyal discusses the latest gadgets and trends in legal technology in Bits & Bytes From trade deals to foreign investment, Patrick Gervais keeps you up to date on business issues in Trade Matters Darcy Merkur brings a plaintiff-side perspective on insurance matters in Personal Injury Law

• Cover