Law Times

Law Times • January 11, 2016 Page 5 www.lawtimesnews.com 16,000 hair samples at issue SickKids' lab didn't meet forensic-testing standards BY NEIL ETIENNE Law Times O ntario Attorney Gener- al Madeleine Meilleur has appointed retired Court of Appeal judge Judith Beaman as commissioner to assist individuals who may have been affected by Motherisk's flawed hair-strand testing. Meilleur made the announce - ment just days aer retired Ontario Court of Appeal justice Susan Lang's independent review of the hair- testing practices at the lab in Toron- to's Hospital for Sick Children was released Dec. 15. Lang, who began the first review in November 2014, found the now-defunct Mother - isk Drug Testing Laboratory never met international forensic-testing standards for hair-strand drug and alcohol testing. "Given my conclusion that the hair-strand drug and alcohol test - ing used by MDTL between 2005 and 2015 was inadequate and un- reliable for use in child protection and criminal proceedings, the use of that evidence has serious impli- cations for the fairness of those pro- ceedings and warrants a further re- view of individual cases or classes of cases," Lang wrote. "Indeed, MDTL's leadership failed to appreciate that the laboratory was doing forensic work. None of the laboratory's lead - ership had any formal training in forensic toxicology." She wrote that in addition to the lab's extensive use in child- protection proceedings, its hair test results were also used as evi- dence in criminal proceedings, although, in contrast to the hair samples from the 16,000-plus in- dividuals tested by MDTL at the request of child-protection agen- cies between 2005 and 2015, few hair samples were processed by the laboratory for criminal matters. Her report found that informa - tion provided to the Independent Review by the Crown Law Office – Criminal identified six crimi- nal cases, including the matter of Tamara Broomfield, which led directly to the review. In that mat- ter, she was convicted and served 49 months in jail for allegedly ad- ministering cocaine to her toddler, in part due to the flawed testing and medical evidence surround- ing it. ose findings were eventu- ally quashed by the appeal court in October 2014, when fresh forensic evidence brought to light the flaws in methodology at Motherisk. "Hopefully, they will be look - ing deeply into the science behind this and how this evidence was so trusted in court given the frailties that were eventually uncovered with it," says lawyer Daniel Brown, who was involved in Broomfield's defence. "is is a symptom of a larger problem, and the problem is fo - rensic testing is being conducted in labs without proper procedures and protocols in place and it's be- ing conducted by labs that simply don't have the qualifications to do the testing they're presenting in courts," Brown says. "We hope that the findings of the inquiry will have broader application; it shouldn't just be an answer to this one isolated problem. What we hope is that these problems don't happen in other cases." Peter Marshall, formerly an in- house lawyer for Children's Aid in Toronto and now president of the Recovery Science Corpora - tion in Bancro that at one point had collected samples for Mother- isk testing before the issues came to light, says that because public confidence has been shaken by the issue, it would be appropriate for the commissioner's mandate to allow review of the practices at other labs. Marshall says increased edu - cation for judges and lawyers in terms of how they interpret sci- entific evidence will be a vital el- ement in restoring public confi- dence as well. Brown says that oen when dealing with scientific, forensic ev- idence, the courts "weren't taking a close enough look at the science, that lawyers weren't challenging the science, and that prosecutors didn't understand the limits of the science when they were present - ing this evidence in court." He says that now that will significantly change and he expects a far higher level of scrutiny by all parties in court, but he adds that through the second review, he hopes the com - missioner's mandate will include ways to train a jury on interpreting such evidence as well. "We assume science is black and white, it's not open for inter - pretation, and there's only one right answer when really it's shades of grey," Brown says. "is was, by all accounts, junk science the way it was being conducted; these were presumptive tests that were being presented as if they were the gold- standard testing." Meanwhile, shortly aer the ministry announced the impend - ing second review, Koskie Minsky LLP announced it would be issu- ing a Notice of Action against the lab and the hospital for the flawed testing methodology in child- protection matters. "e lawsuit will allege that both Motherisk and SickKids were negligent in a failure to meet in - ternationally recognized forensic standards with its hair testing and a failure to provide proper oversight to ensure the quality, proficiency and accreditation of its tests," it wrote in a press release announc - ing the upcoming notice. Family law specialist Steven Benmor says it's not a surprising development even if "we don't of - ten hear the words class action in family law." "It was and is a fairly large event to the extent that there were peo - ple who have lost custody of their children to the state in part over incorrect findings by Motherisk," says Benmor. "Number one [prior - ity for the commissioner] will be establishing standards of practices that would be considered mini- mum standards of practice, and that's exactly what the Koskie Min- sky lawsuit is alleging." Benmor says that will require an international review of the bare minimum standards for testing. "e testing must be rigorous and the commissioner hopefully will suggest recommendations whereby there will be some back- check installed where there will be regular monitoring of the agency, the laboratory that's performing these services," he adds, saying ran - dom testing should also be part of the oversight. "I hope the commis- sioner and the report provide very practical tools . . . not just [for] the laboratories that will operate but for the legal system to know how to properly examine forensic evi - dence, what questions we should be asking in order to form an opin- ion as to the validity of expert evi- dence." For its part, SickKids released an apology following the release of Lang's review, quoting the hos - pital's president and CEO Dr. Mi- chael Apkon: "We deeply regret that practices in, and oversight of this particular program did not meet SickKids standards of excel - lence. We extend our apologies to anyone who feels they may have been impacted. "SickKids is fully committed to addressing the recommendations and will work closely with the commissioner once appointed," the release states. "We remain re - solved in our efforts to ensure that we have effective oversight and the highest standards of quality and safety in all of our programs." It further states that the hospi - tal now requires all summons and subpoenas to its clinicians and scientists be reviewed by the legal department and that it is imple - menting a training program to ensure that staff who prepare re- ports and testify in court have the appropriate training and context with regards to their roles and re- sponsibilities. LT NEWS 'We assume science is black and white…when really it's shades of grey,' says Daniel Brown. This is more than a phone book. It is your instant connection to Canada's legal network. With Canadian Law List 2016 you have access to: • an up-to-date alphabetical listing of more than 80,000 barristers, solicitors BOE2VFCFDOPUBSJFTDPSQPSBUFDPVOTFMMBXȮSNTBOEKVEHFTBDSPTT$BOBEB • all contact information supplied for the Supreme Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada, Federal Cabinet Ministers, departments, boards, commissions and Crown Corporations • legal and government contact information related to each province for the Courts of Appeal, Supreme Courts, County and District Courts, Provincial Courts, law societies, law schools, Legal Aid and other important MBXSFMBUFEPGȮDFT THE LATEST CONTACT INFORMATION IN A USER-FRIENDLY FORMAT THAT IS BEYOND TRADITIONAL LISTINGS Continually updated by a dedicated team of professionals, Canadian Law List includes value added features such as: • lBTUOBNFȮSTUJEFOUJȮDBUJPOJOUIFGFEFSBMBOEQSPWJODJBMMJTUJOHT • separate section of corporate law departments for more than 1,250 companies • pSPGFTTJPOBMDBSETPGQSPNJOFOU$BOBEJBOMBXȮSNT • International Agency Referral Cards AREAS OF PRACTICE AND ENHANCED LISTING INDEX The enhanced listing index is displayed in bold type with detailed practice information. It also: • lJTUTȮSNTBOEMBXZFSTUIBUIBWFFYQBOEFEUIFJSQSBDUJDFJOGPSNBUJPOJOUIFJS provincial listing • is organized by areas of practice by province, city and page reference in their provincial listings Hardbound • Published February each year • L88804-765 • On subscription $169* • One time purchase $188* Multiple copy discounts available * Plus shipping/handling and applicable taxes ORDER YOUR COPY TODAY! Call 1.800.387.5164 or visit www.carswell.com KEEPING PACE WITH THE CHANGING LEGAL COMMUNITY FOR OVER 130 YEARS Untitled-1 1 2016-01-06 9:23 AM I hope the commissioner and the report provide very practical tools . . . not just [for] the laboratories that will operate but for the legal system to know how to properly examine forensic evidence . . . Steven Benmor

• Cover