The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario
Issue link: https://digital.lawtimesnews.com/i/820392
Page 10 May 8, 2017 • Law TiMes www.lawtimesnews.com Need for genetic discrimination bills questioned BY MICHAEL MCKIERNAN For Law Times A Toronto employment lawyer has questioned the need for genetic discrimination protec- tion as two bills on the issue pick up steam at Queen's Park and Parliament in Ottawa. In Ontario, bill 30, co- sponsored by Liberal MPP Mike Colle and his Progressive Conservative colleague Sylvia Jones, would add "genetic char- acteristics" to the list of prohib- ited grounds of discrimination under the province's Human Rights Code. The act is cur- rently being studied by the leg- islature's justice policy standing committee. Meanwhile, at the federal lev- el, bill S-201, which is expected to receive Royal assent in the near future, would make similar amendments to the Canadian Human Rights Act and the Can- ada Labour Code. But Lisa Cabel, a partner in the Toronto office of Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP, says the measures will have little im- pact on employers, since predis- position to a genetic condition could be considered a form of disability, an already-protected ground under the codes. "Therefore, workers are al- ready protected under existing legislation," she says, adding that employers should already "have policies or procedures in place with respect to employees or potential employees with dis- abilities." "From an employer/employee standpoint, these measures are largely unnecessary. There is very little evidence that this kind of discrimination exists," Cabel adds. In the U.S., where the Genetic Information NonDiscrimina- tion Act has been in force since 2008, she says the law generates only a few hundred complaints every year across the nation, generally relating to the denial of basic health coverage. "Since we have universal pub- lic health coverage in Canada, this is less of an issue," Cabel says. Until S-201 completes its leg- islative journey, Canada will re- main the only G7 nation not to have taken action on the issue as genetic testing grows in popu- larity around the world. "We've seen a number of ju- risdictions respond to very vo- cal concerns from some groups about how the information will be used and attempting to pro- tect people from misuse," says Carole Piovesan, a litigator in the Toronto office of McCarthy Tétrault LLP. "What we have here seems to be a made-in-Can- ada take on the issue." Dara Jospé, a lawyer with a focus on life sciences regulation at Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP, says discussion about ge- netic discrimination in human rights legislation dates all the way back to the late 1990s, when former Supreme Court justice Gérard La Forest conducted a review of Canada's federal hu- man rights law. His final report recommended the definition of "disability" be expanded to in- clude the predisposition to being disabled. "Since then, we've had bill af- ter bill in various provinces and at the federal level," Jospé says. "It's never been the right time or had enough support to go through, but this time it looks as though it will." Toronto health lawyer Omar Ha-Redeye says he welcomes the legislation, in the hope it will provide a potential boost to the development of individualized approaches to health care based on a patient's genetic profile. "We're only just beginning to understand the complexity of the human genome, and it's going to take us a couple of de- cades for us to fully get there. In the meantime, I would hate to see fallacious assumptions being made about genetic traits," Ha- Redeye says. However, the federal bill has raised the hackles of the insur- ance industry because of extra provisions that contemplate criminal sanctions in the en- forcement of the ban on genetic discrimination. S-201 outlaws requirements that people undergo genetic test- ing or disclose the results of pre- vious tests as a condition of em- ployment or service provision. The unauthorized sharing of a person's genetic results could also be met with criminal penal- ties under the law. That prospect prompted Fed- eral Justice Minister Jody Wil- son-Raybould and Prime Min- ister Justin Trudeau to speak out against the bill when it came before the House of Commons. Government amendments pro- posed in the lower chamber would have cut the bill back to focus on the addition of genetic characteristics as a prohibited ground in the CHRA, but they were defeated in a free vote, in fa- vour of the tougher version that had earlier passed the Senate. The federal government has since suggested it will send the legislation to the Supreme Court of Canada for a reference to set- tle the question of whether it vi- olates the Constitution by using criminal law to regulate insur- ance companies, an area under provincial jurisdiction. The reference could be good news for the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association Inc., whose membership ac- counts for 99 per cent of the in- dustry in this country. Spokes- man Stephen Frank said in a statement that the group was "extremely disappointed" when the House of Commons passed S-201 virtually unchanged from the version that exited the Senate. "The industry agrees with the federal government's posi- tion as expressed by the prime minister and the minister of Justice, as well as a number of provinces, that an important element of the bill is unconsti- tutional," he said. LT FOCUS Lisa Cabel says two bills related to genetic discrimination will have little impact on employers. HOSTED IN PARTNERSHIP WITH BRONZE SPONSOR PLATINUM SPONSOR NO TRANSFORMATION WITHOUT INSPIRATION The Canadian Lawyer InHouse Innovatio Awards celebrate in-house counsel, both individuals and teams, who have found ways to show leadership by becoming more efficient, innovative and creative in meeting the needs of their organizations within the Canadian legal market. Date: Sept. 19, 2017 Location: Arcadian Court, Toronto 6 p.m. Cocktail Reception 7 p.m. Gala Dinner and Awards Presentation Emcee: Jennifer Brown, Managing Editor, Canadian Lawyer InHouse/Law Times Dress: Business Attire To book your seats or to inquire about sponsorship, contact us at 416-649-8841 or MediaSolutions.Sales@thomsonreuters.com www.innovatio-awards.com GOLD SPONSOR Untitled-5 1 2017-04-28 3:10 PM