Law Times

Page 4 November 20, 2017 • Law Times www.lawtimesnews.com Kenora lawyer launches $7-million lawsuit against LSUC BY ALEX ROBINSON Law Times A Kenora lawyer has launched a $7-million lawsuit against the Law Society of Upper Canada, claiming the provincial regulator maliciously prosecut- ed him. Doug Keshen filed a state- ment of claim this summer in Ontario Superior Court after the law society dropped a case against him concerning allega- tions he had exploited residential school survivors he represented. Since it found the allegations were untrue, the law society publicly acknowledged Keshen's case exposed systemic problems in its hearing process and ap- pointed a panel to review how it regulates processes that affect indigenous peoples. But this was not enough for Keshen. The lawyer is now su- ing the law society for abuse of process, misfeasance in public office, defamation, malicious prosecution and negligence. He claims the law society's ac- tions were "malicious, egregious and highhanded" and that the regulator's conduct "revictim- ized" and traumatized residen- tial school survivors involved in the proceedings. "It is conduct not befitting of a public body that this court should condemn and deter in the public interest," said his statement of claim. The law soci- ety started its investigation into Keshen in 2014 in order to look into rumours he had been steal- ing from his clients. Keshen had exclusively represented indig- enous clients since he moved to Kenora, Ont. in 1978. A former councillor of one of the bands to which Keshan provided legal services started the rumours when the lawyer refused to pay him a share of his fees, according to the statement of claim. That councillor had demanded payment for having facilitated Keshen's communi- cations with clients in the band. He then filed a complaint to the law society and also suggest- ed to a number of band mem- bers that Keshen had ripped them off. From there, the rumours spread throughout the com- munity and beyond. Members of the band filed more than 20 complaints years after Keshen's retainer had ended. Keshen claimed it should have been ap- parent to LSUC investigators that the source of the rumours was unreliable and that they were in possession of evidence that proved some of the allega- tions were false. He said that law society in- vestigators conducted inter- views with his clients in an "in- competent and closed-minded" way, asking leading questions that elicited answers consistent with their own theories. The statement of claim said the law society also solicited fur- ther complaints against Keshen by setting up drop-in centres in the area so that Keshen's cli- ents could come to tell the law society of any problems they had with him. And in doing so, Keshen claimed the law society enlisted the help of an area in- digenous political organization that the lawyer's firm was litigat- ing against on behalf of several bands that were disputing the extent of its authority. The law society then started proceedings against Keshen be- fore the investigation was com- plete in what the lawyer said was a premature prosecution. The proceedings went ahead despite his warnings about the dan- gers of making such allegations public. The law society typi- cally does not make allegations against lawyers public until their proceeding reaches the hearing stage. But as law society pros- ecutors filed a notice of applica- tion before the investigation was complete, that was when the al- legations became public. The law society sent an email out to hundreds of peers in the indigenous bar and potential cli- ents with the notice of application that set out the allegations against Keshen, according to the state- ment of claim. Keshen said that this was part of a "self-serving" public relations campaign the law society was engaging in to try to "repair" it's reputation after me- dia reports came out that it had failed to prosecute lawyers who had exploited Roma clients. The law society eventually withdrew most of the allegations in Febru- ary of this year and the disciplin- ary tribunal panel dismissed the rest in the spring. But, by that time, the investi- gation and the media attention the case received had effectively ended Keshen's career and ru- ined his reputation. Keshen lost almost all his clients, had to leave his firm and has suffered psy- chological injury from the years- long affair, his claim said. "The society's commence- ment of the conduct proceed- ings and its attendant public re- lations campaign, including the mass email, caused irreparable damage to Mr. Keshen's repu- tation," the statement of claim said. A spokeswoman for the law society declined to comment on Keshen's statement of claim. Keshen also declined to com- ment on the lawsuit, but he said the claim has not been served yet to the law society. Daniel Naymark, one of the lawyers who represented Keshen in the law society proceedings, has said in previous interviews that the accusations hung over Keshen for longer than neces- sary because of the way the law society publicized the charges. Naymark is not representing Keshen in the civil action and declined to comment for this story. Keshen is seeking $5 million in special damages, $1 million in general damages, $500,000 for psychological injury and $500,000 for aggravated and pu- nitive damages. LT NEWS NEWS NEWS Doug Keshen has filed a lawsuit against the Law Society of Upper Canada for mali- cious prosecution, defamation and neg- ligence. Order your copy today. Visit www.store.thomsonreuters.ca or call 1-800-387-5164 for a 30-day, no risk evaluation ONTARIO LAWYER'S PHONE BOOK 2018 Ontario Lawyer's Phone Book is your best connection to legal services in Ontario with more than 1,400 pages of essential legal references. You can depend on the accuracy of this trusted directory that includes the most up-to-date names, phone numbers, mailing addresses and emails so you don't have to search anywhere else. More detail and a wider scope of legal contact information for Ontario: • Over 26,800 lawyers listed • Over 8,500 law firms and corporate offices listed • Fax and telephone numbers, e-mail addresses, office locations and postal codes Includes lists of: • Federal and provincial judges • Federal courts, including a section for federal government departments, boards and commissions • Ontario courts and services, including a section for provincial government ministries, boards and commissions • Small claims courts • The Institute of Law Clerks of Ontario • Miscellaneous services for lawyers Perfectbound Published December each year On subscription $85 One time purchase $88.50 L7798-7858 Multiple copy discounts available Plus applicable taxes and shipping & handling. (prices subject to change without notice) Your instant connection to ONTARIO'S LEGAL NETWORK Untitled-4 1 2017-11-13 1:38 PM

• Cover