Law Times

June 18, 2018

The premier weekly newspaper for the legal profession in Ontario

Issue link:

Contents of this Issue


Page 2 of 15

Law Times • June 18, 2018 Page 3 Jury selection report shows system biased, say lawyers BY DALE SMITH For Law Times A report by a judge in Ot- tawa is making waves among lawyers because it reveals the statistics about the composition of juries in two Eastern Ontario regions. Lawyers say the report shows how the system can be biased. The report, written by On- tario Superior Court Justice Giovanna Toscano Roccamo while on a study leave at the Uni- versity of Ottawa's law school, uses the 2016 jury lists provided by the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General and compares it with census data from the same year to identify the com- position of criminal and civil ju- ries in Ottawa and the Belleville areas. The report looks at a total of 5,500 prospective jurors and concludes that juries in the areas studied are 10 times more likely to be drawn from predominant- ly white, middle-class neigh- bourhoods than poor, racialized ones. The Belleville area was also chosen because it contains a First Nation; juries chosen from that region in 2016 contained no Indigenous jurors, says the report. "Over the course of years of jury trial experience, I formed the impression that the modern jury did not always appear to represent the 'conscience of the community'," wrote Toscano Roccamo in her report. "My an- ecdotal experience was that the jury selection process, possibly compounded by the exercise of judicial discretion, habitu- ally excluded from service racial and linguistic minorities, low- income earners, students, and caregivers." The trend of jury represen- tativeness was the driving force behind Toscano Roccamo's re- port, according to the report. Toscano Roccamo declined to comment for the story. Toscano Roccamo also noted the timeliness of the study given the press coverage of the cases involving the deaths of Indig- enous youths Colten Boushie in Saskatchewan and Tina Fon- taine in Manitoba. The report comes with no analysis or rec- ommendations, which was a conscious decision on the part of Toscano Roccamo. "As a sitting justice of the Su- perior Court of Justice for On- tario, I have not and will not play a part in advancing any politi- cal agenda incorporating policy changes and legislative reforms directed at enhancing jury rep- resentativeness," Toscano Roc- camo wrote in the report. The report — which is now publicly available through the Canadian Judicial Council — has attracted the attention of the defence bar. "It provides objective empiri- cal data [that] proves that white, wealthy, home-owning Ottawa- ns are exponentially more likely to be chosen for a jury than poor, racialized people living in rental or community housing," says Solomon Friedman, managing partner with Edelson & Fried- man Barristers LLP in Ottawa, who is also the treasurer of the Defence Counsel Association of Ottawa. "That's offensive to our un- derstanding of a jury trial," adds Friedman. "The state doesn't get to select which types of people it wants on a jury. " Friedman says that, for his practice, the juries are not rep- resentative of the people who come before the court because of systemic issues in the system. "The way juries are selected in Ontario is fundamentally un- fair and f lawed," says Friedman. "By relying on the Munici- pal Property Assessment Cor- poration, the system selects for homeowners only." Ontario's Debwewin Com- mittee, formed in 2013 to report back on how to improve the par- ticipation of Indigenous people in the jury process, is years over- due in making its final recom- mendations. The Ministry of the Attor- ney General told Law Times in August 2017 that the final report was being prepared, but it has still not been released. In her report, Toscano Roc- camo stated that she chose the two regions based on time and resources available to her. Friedman says that he doesn't believe there are any other stud- ies on jury composition available in Ontario. The Canadian Judicial Coun- cil notes that Toscano Roc- camo's study leave was granted by the Governor in Council and that five or six judges take study leaves each year in order to en- gage in research or to teach at a Canadian institution. "As Justice Toscano Roc- camo's report included some information that could be of interest to the public, her report was made public in an effort to contribute to the discussion," said CJC director of communi- cations Johanna Laporte in an emailed response. "The council expresses no views on the merits or her findings." Michael Lacy, president of The Criminal Lawyers' Asso- ciation, says the results of the re- port could easily be extrapolated to Ontario regions other than just Ottawa and Belleville. Lacy notes that, while the federal government is proposing changes to how juries are select- ed from pools, such as eliminat- ing peremptory challenges, the CLA opposes the move because the actual issue is the lack of di- versity in the jury pool itself. "That's the job of the prov- ince, not the job of the federal government," says Lacy. LT NEWS Solomon Friedman says a recent report 'provides objective empirical data [that] proves that white, wealthy, home-owning Ottawans are exponentially more likely to be chosen for a jury than poor, racial- ized people living in rental or community housing.' This is more than a phone book. With Canadian Law List 2018 you have access to: • an up-to-date alphabetical listing of more than 80,000 barristers, solicitors and Quebec notaries, corporate counsel, law firms and judges across Canada • all contact information supplied for the Supreme Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada, Federal Cabinet Ministers, departments, boards, commissions and Crown Corporations • legal and government contact information related to each province for the Courts of Appeal, Supreme Courts, County and District Courts, Provincial Courts, law societies, law schools, Legal Aid and other important law-related offices THE LATEST CONTACT INFORMATION IN A USER-FRIENDLY FORMAT THAT IS BEYOND TRADITIONAL LISTINGS Continually updated by a dedicated team of professionals, Canadian Law List includes value added features such as: • last name first identification in the federal and provincial listings • separate section of corporate law departments for more than 1,250 companies • professional cards of prominent Canadian law firms • International Agency Referral Cards Hardbound • Published February each year • L7798-7859 • On subscription $179* • One time purchase $199* Multiple copy discounts available * Plus shipping/handling and applicable taxes ORDER YOUR COPY TODAY! Call 1.800.387.5164 or visit for a 30-day no-risk evaluation KEEPING PACE WITH THE CHANGING LEGAL COMMUNITY Untitled-2 1 2018-06-12 10:12 AM CALL FOR NOMINATIONS The Lexpert® Rising Stars: Leading Lawyers Under 40 honours lawyers from law firms, in-house and alternative practices. We encourage lawyers to nominate other lawyers from firms, in-house and government with whom they have worked. The Awards presentation is the centrepiece of a gala dinner scheduled for November 8 th , 2018, at the Fairmont Royal York Hotel in Toronto. Nominations close July 13 th , 2018. To nominate a colleague and/or access the nomination criteria, please visit us online: FOUNDING PARTNER Untitled-1 1 2018-06-15 8:46 AM

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Law Times - June 18, 2018